World close to the brink as Anti Assad forces capture Russian Pilot downed by Turks.

Following the downing of the Russian bomber this morning I can only be grateful that the world’s major powers have a common enemy in ISIL

As regards the Turks under a putative Sunni demagogue Rycyp Erdogan I can only think with friends like these who needs enemies.

Turkey’s New Ottomanism foreign policy has been a disaster and perhaps should be alternately known as  Neo Byzantinism in view of the double dealing and continued regards to Turkey’s relationship with extreme groups in Syria.

I personally witnessed the facilitation of the foreign jihadi fighters that make up the Katibas of Al Nursra, Al Sham and ISIL  while working as a journalist in Antakya, as recruits from the Magreb Chechnya and Europe were granted free passage through South East Turkey  into Aleppo and Idlib province across the border in Syria.

Not only were they allowed to come en masse to meet with recruiters, they were able to cross back and forth for Rest and Recreation and medical treatment in Antakya.

Meanwhile local traders did a roaring trade in non lethal military kit.

Others in the back street tea houses and coffee shops steered the way to illegal arms.

While princes and sheiks from Qatar rolled up in  armoured Limos with entourages of imans and bodyguards to disburse millions of dollars to residents of Syrian refugee camps while espousing anti Assad Israeli and Shia rhetoric as their price.

One can only speculate if the  dollars went on recruitment for the fight against Assad, but then again neither was there evidence that the conditions in the camps improved significantly either.

This was 2012 since which time the province around Antakya with its large Allawi and Arab population has been teetering on the brink of revolt .

The local Allawites or Allevis many with relatives across the border in Syria mostly support Assad and are not afraid to tell you so.

There were already pre existing tensions with local Turkish Sunni moslems who were brought in to the area by Attaturk before the second World War in order to make up the numbers of Ethnic Turks voting yes to annexation by Turkey.

The plebiscite was offered by France who then ruled over Greater Syria following the collapse of Ottoman rule after the first world war. It was 1939 and the French  were eager to bring Turkey into the war against Nazi Germany.

Since July 2015 Turkey has supposedly been involved in operations against ISIL yet has been persistent in its criticism of Russian involvement

Understandably Turkey has been vociferous against Assad’s atrocities against Syrian civilians, but was muted when its alleged proxy ISIL has been deliberately and systematically conducting brutal genocide against Yazedis Shia’s and Christians .

It has condemned Russia’s bombing campaign and seen to be lukewarm in its pursuit of  ISIL preferring to target Kurds who are directly  fighting ISIL .

And now we have the most positionally suspect NATO member downing a Russian Jet with the death of its two pilots.

Most worryingly one of the pilots seems to have been killed by yet another of the Turks proxies anti Assad Turkmen paramilitaries.

The gruesome displaying of the pilot’s body in the usual display of triumphalism by these groups will not play well on the world stage least of all in Moscow.

If it transpires that the jet was brought down on the border or inside Syrian airspace it denudes Ankara of any fig leaf in relation to their real policy intentions of protecting their proxies rather than joining in a untied front against extremist militant groups fighting Assad.

The Russians muted response so far gives hope that they may realise they have to concede that the jet was in fact well into Turkish airspace. I

f that is the case Turkey can expect to find itself at the wrong end of Russian trade and foreign relations.

However if Russia deems its plane was well inside Syrian airspace then Turkey must face some sort existential military response from Russia.

If that is the case, Governments in the West and NATO would be well advised to steer  clear of supporting Turkey in what is a situation all of its own making and against the wider policy aims of the West and its allies in the Middle East and the wider world.

Countries like France, UK and even the USA, will hopefully see that Russia is a more valued ally in the fight against a common enemy than a double dealing Turkey, self serving its own nefarious regional policies and interests.



Posted in News | 2 Comments

High or low No Good Guys or Bad Guys

IMG_8059Following the downing of the Malaysian Airlines flight killing nearly 300 tourists and air crew The presumed involvement of the seperatists in this horrible act has cast them even further in the role of the bad guys in the conflict raging between Ukrainian Government forces and the pro Russian Militias.
There is a counter narrative of course seldom heard in the West.
That is of a group of Russian speaking Ukrainians who feared that their language rights and economic needs were about to be subsumed amidst the euphoria emerging from the overthrow of Russophile Party of the Regions earlier in the year.
The revolution centered on Indepedence (Maidan) square in Kiev espoused a greater assertion of Ukrainian nationalism championed by groups such as the Right Sector and Svoboda both of which are percieved as fascist even NAZI by pro Russian activists in the Donbass region in which many citizens still harbor a degree of nostalgia for the former Soviet system .
Russians cannot forget or forgive the idealogical links these parties have to the Ukrainian resistance movement of Stepan Bandera who fought for Ukranian independence against the Russian dominated Soviet State.
Despite Bandera’s arrest and detention by the distrusting Germans, his Ukrainian Nationalist miltias often fought alongside regular German Amy forces in Ukraine against Soviet forces.
The decision to install Bandera by outgoing President Yuschenko as a national hero in 2010 raised the hackles of many Ukrainians, both Russian and Ukrainian speakers alike.
Not least those Soviet veterans that had suffered directly from the NAZI invasion.
The initial pro Russian protests in April that called for federalisation rather than indepence or Anchluss with Russia, saw local activists arrested by the SBU the Ukrainian KGB equivalent.
Arrests and detentions of activists such as DNR “Peoples Govenor” Paul Gubarev led to the kidnapping of officials loyal to Kiev, the storming of police stations and the militarisation of the conflict.
Just how much direct interference there has been from Russia is unclear, the rebels equipment has been supplemented from the Russain side of the border without doubt including Grad rocket systems and Russian Man Pad rockets.
Whether the equipment has been facilitated by the Russian central government or by rogue elelments acting independently allocating quasi surplus equipment is not certain.
The seperatists do not have massive amounts of materiel and they have been pushed back from key towns such as Sloviansk in the past month.
During this retreat back into the major centres of Donetsk and Luhansk seperatist leaders have berated President Putin for not coming to their aid.
Before the MH-17 crash I and other Journalists were aware that delagations of DNR activists were in Moscow frantically attempting to muster support from political figures close to Putin and the Kremlin.
Against this background for most ordinary people on the ground in Eastern Ukraine there are no good guys or bad guys just too many people with guns and rockets who are holding sway over their lives.
In the case of ordinary Ukranians the Ukranian National Army are far from the good guys and for many with good reason.

I have come across one such family of Ukranian Russian speakers in their mid thirties with a young child, living in the Ukranian border town of Amvorieska.
Professionals working as an eletrical engineer and draughtswoman, the couple and their young son enjoyed a high standard of living povided by their combined salaries of around 50,000 dollars.
Last month a Ukrainian National Army rocket unit had established a base just outside Amvorieska on the road linking Donestk and Rostov in Russia.
The family’s happy existence came to an abrupt and violent end in the early hours of June 15th as two Ukranian Army missiles crashed into their house.
One half of the couple Alinna described the incident saying “We were very lucky that night, because my husband decided to sleep with the baby in another room.
‘My friend visited and she and I sat together chatting in the kitchen.
At 2:30 am, I saw through the window something flying towards the house., and a second later it was within 2 metres a 1 metre flying projectile.
The projectile broke through two walls in the kitchen and continued into the yard.
Seconds later in the middle of the house a beam fell from the roof onto my son’s playpen smashing it into smithereens, it also broke through the walls in the kitchen.
We were so lucky that the first missile flew through the house, during this time we managed run out into the street.
“My husband grabbed our son and we all went down into a basement in a neighbour’s house.
The shelling lasted for about 30 minutes.
After the bombardment the couple emerged to be confonted by a scene of complete destruction.
Alinna continued. “There was almost nothing let of our home, roof walls, windows everything was destroyed All our stuff were under a pile of building stones!
“After the losing our home we just did not know what to do next .”

At least another five homes in the village were destroyed and 25 damaged.
The family has now sought refuge amongst their ethnic kin folk, understandably they are terrified of their future in Ukraine amongst Ukrainians, Alinna explained: “Now we are in Taganrog (Russia),we escaped right away – on the next day after the incident.
“Next week we go to Moscow to relatives. They promised to help with the work and give the apartment for free for a year. That’s it!
“It seems peoples lives from the Donetsk region are unpredictable for a long time to come.
“All is well today and tomorrow you are on the street without any documents and possessions and without a roof over our heads.
It all happened so fast and was so scary that we still can not come to our senses. Alinna added “My son Vadim (3 years)is now reacting to all sounds, when he hears thunder he is hiding under the bed any loud noises and the whole family is unable to withstand them psychologically.”

Despite the family’s desperate plight the compensation they received from the Ukranian State in the first instantce amounted to little more than two hundred dollars.
Alinna explained: “Our house was conffered to the first level of destruction and was not recognized to stay (stand up). Here I have a certificate from our village council.” (See picture supplied)
Apart from the emergency payment there was no help or even interest from any other official body 

 The Ukranian military, the rebel DNR the local police, fire brigade and local council refused to become involved .The family received just one early morning visit from an official of the Ministry of Emergency Situations.
Even now the family still have no real explanation as to what happened and why their house came under fire.
Alinna feels sure the rockets came from a Ukranian National Army rocket unit, that was stationed close by she says: “I cannot exactly say who fired because I did not see who was shooting, but along the trajectory from where the the projectile came from, you can understand the place from where it was fired. At this point is located the Ukrainian army, we have understood they were shooting from the factory farm where the National Guard were posistioned with the anti-aircraft installations.”
She had no idea why they were shooting in the direction of her village she is adamant that there were no DNR checkpoints no militias posistions or activity.
As far she understands the DNR are not present in her town even now. Alinna states: “Only on the maps of the Anti Terrorist Operations are the DNR located here, the people here are neutral, they do not support the Ukrainian government or the DNR.

Alinna was also dismissive of the closeness to the border with Russia (Uspenka)as a reason for the bombardment , she is clear there was no passage of Military equipment from Russia certainly at the time of the assault.
With absolute clarity she states “ There was only the Ukrainian Army here, a lot of them, in every village with an huge amount of military equipment.

We know the National Guard was around Amrosievki and Ilovajsk and no DNR, we heard the National Army got drunk and fired at us.”
“I can not officially confirm this, but I can confidently say that it was not the militia (DNR), because they were not here – the Ukrainian Army was everywhere. I understand the National Guard fired with anti-aircraft guns on the Saur-Grave, (WW2 memorial occupying high ground NE of Amvrosivielka ) with the same success they could shoot to us.
It is only because one these shells failed to explode that are alive to tell the story”
This is the kind of story known to thousands of civilians of both ethnicities across Eastern Ukraine.
For thousands of civilians caught between the two armies whether on the ground or 30, 000 feet up in the air there are no good or bad guys just too many with bombs and guns. Ends.

Posted in News | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Donetsk Despatch





Boystov The leader of the rebel volunteer battalion

The fate of Donetsk,city of one million, rests in hands of a 26 year-old commander recruited by social media.
All out war and humanitarian disaster looms dangerously close with increasing hardships for residents.
By Nigel Pivaro.1st published in Die Zeit 10/7/14





Two years ago Donetsk was playing host to thousands of England football fans during the European Championships, today this city of one million is teetering on the brink of an all out war.
As the battered remnants of self styled Separatist commander Gregor Strelkov’s fighters retreat from Slaviansk and regroup in this formerly prosperous industrial city, normal life is beginning to fall apart.
Water is restricted to 2 hours a day due to bomb damage to filtration plants, interruptions to electricity and internet services are becoming more frequent and lasting for longer.
Supermarkets are refusing credit card transactions and cash is no longer available from the cash machines. The few banks that remain open do so for only two hours a day.
Residents are reporting increasing incidents of robbery, kidnap and assaults at the hands of elements of the Donetsk Peoples Army (Donetsk Narody Army)
One family told me they were visited by soldiers of the DNA who ransacked the house and stole 50, 000 Ghrivnas around £2500.
They did what the rebel army has advised residents to do in case of a complaint about the conduct of separatists soldiers – they called the emergency hotline .
Within a few minutes officers and troops from the DNA arrived at the family’s house in time to catch their colleagues who were leaving. Instead of the first group of soldiers being arrested and the money returned as the family had hoped the second group decided that the family could have their money returned if the father and eldest joined the Separatist Army if not the money would be their contribution to the war effort. The family decided on the donation.
Worryingly for residents this type of incident along with car hijacking to facilitate rebel troops with transport is on the increase.
Donetsk a coal and steel town (think a Soviet era type Sheffield) founded 150 years ago by a Welshman, John Hughes, is the centre of the self proclaimed Donetsk Peoples Republic, following the violent takeover of the regional administration building in April.
Pro-Russian rebels went further after a referendum in May (not recognised outside the region) which the rebels say returned a majority of votes in favour of independence from Ukraine.
The Donetsk rebels linked up with the neighbouring region of Lughansk to declare the confederation of Novo Russiya (New Russia).
In the interim Ukrainian forces have been slowly and painfully attempting to bring the region back under their control.
The countryside and towns around have seen increasing fighting that has so far claimed at least 500 civilian casualties and countless more numbers of rebel fighters and loyalist Ukrainian troops.
Speaking exclusively to me from with the barricaded rebel stronghold in the former Interior Ministry Police HQ the commander of the Orthodox Battalion of the Donetsk Peoples Army 26 -year-old Dymytry Boytsov (Nom de Guerre) said: “ Our aim is not war but we stand ready to defend the people from the Kiev Nazis who are coming with their alien ideology, they want to impose different cultures and traditions on us.
“We are Russians by nature, we want to defend religious freedom and the multi national background of the region.
“We have had the referendum we just want to be heard and for the world to recognise we are different .”
The fate of Donetsk and its one million inhabitants now rests with this militarily inexperienced young man his face hidden behind a camouflage mask for fear of reprisals.
Dimitry openly admits to having little combat experience apart from that gained in the recent takeover.
In fact he says he became involved in the separatist movement via the VK social media network the Russian equivalent of Facebook.
I ask Dimitry “Are the Separatists prepared to stay embedded in the built up areas of the city and risk the lives of the civilian population. ?”
“Yes why should we leave our fortified areas so we will become vulnerable to the Ukrainians.”
What about the safety of the civilians who will be caught in the crossfire and bombardments? Rather casually the Commander answers: “ We will try to defend the civilians and facilitate their safety with instructions and advice.
“We do not want to disappoint the population saying : “We will take some of the civilians out of the city.”
Though he did not offer any clear idea where hundreds of thousands of people will go he added:“There are bomb shelters ready and we will declare martial law to keep order.”
“We are not going to leave,we are ready to accept volunteers with the same ideology we demand that the Ukrainian troops give us a chance to develop ourselves and leave us to our own choices.”
“We do not want to be sold to the USA ! Why is it only Nazi people are helped? Why is there no help for the Russian people.
“We want help from Russia we hope they will help us.”
“The world’s media says we are being supplied by Russia with heavy weaponry – that is not true- where are the heavy guns from Russia?
We have only light weapons that we took from the armouries of the Ukrainian Police”.
As we leave the Separatist’s stronghold in the HQ of the former Ukrainian Secret Police (SBU) reinforced with sandbag dug outs and concrete blocks, a car backfires and my young female interpreter freezes in fear.
“Its alright its just a car! a sentry shouts as she allows herself a nervous laugh.
Following our two hour interview we headed into the city centre to enjoy some respite from the tension of the possible looming catastrophe.
The bars, restaurants, cafes and shops that adorn the wide boulevards of this pleasant city and have just enough customers to give the impression of normality.
Despite the armed Separatists manning the roadside checkpoints, the water shortages, power cuts and constant threats from the Kiev Government that the attack will come very soon, life goes on… just.
However something will have to give, the Ukrainian Army will build up its forces outside the city after clearing the separatists from the key strategic towns of Slavyansk and Kramatorsk to prepare the ground for the final assault on its most important objective.
If the rebels reject Ukrainian President Poroshenko’s peace plan with its offer of safe passage into Russia , then there is no alternative to a bloody battle that will add to the growing list of casualties. That will turn the stream of 34,000 refugees from war torn areas into a deluge numbering the hundreds of thousands.
Thats when the inexperienced Commander Boystov of the Orthodox Battalion will have to quickly learn the full challenge that his decision to remain in his city HQ will bring on the 900 fighters and one million inhabitants under his control.
There is no doubt if the separatists do remain embedded within the city then the consequences for the civilians trapped there will be horrendous. Ends.

Posted in Mainstream media published articles, News, Previous newspaper published articles, Top Stories | Tagged , | 1 Comment